Should I Ignore a Strike 3 Holdings Subpoena? Straight Answers

Share

Short answer: you can choose not to respond, but if you ignore a Strike 3 Holdings subpoena letter, the case usually does not go away. It mostly means decisions get made without you. Below are the questions people ask most, in the words they may use on Reddit and in search, with plain answers.

NEVER Ignore being served with a Strike 3 Holdings Summons and Amended Complaint

Its an important distinction between being served with a Summons and Amended Complaint versus just getting a letter from your Internet Company (ISP) informing you that THEY received a court-ordered Subpoena to release your name and address. Its easy to get these confused when reading about these lawsuits online – I would get them confused myself as a beginning attorney when I got my first job at a law firm! I never want anybody misunderstanding what they read online (or worse, reading what someone online wrote in a forum, that was legally *wrong*) and then ignoring the wrong thing, and paying dearly for it. If you have a question about what you think you have received, call or make an appointment online for a free confidential consultation with Antonelli Law.

You can read about the two-part Default Judgment process in federal court in this document written by federal Judge Margaret R. Guzman of the District of Massachusettes

The case I link to below with the $1.5 Million default judgment against a defendant in federal court in Chicago was a real case we saw in person ourselves back in 2012, in court, with our own eyes. I remember just not believing my ears that the judge actually awarded the movie company the fullest possible amount available under the Copyright Act – for someone who didn’t show up in court, file paperwork with the Clerk of the Court, or hire an attorney.

IMPORTANT: Never ignore being served with a Summons and Amended Complaint. Getting notified by your ISP that they received a Subpoena from Strike 3 Holdings is a vastly different matter than you being served with a Summons and lawsuit Complaint. Anyone who is served with a Summons and fails to file proper court papers (or hire an attorney) within the time limit can be held to be in default. A default judgment under Rule 55 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure is an extremely serious matter. It is rare (and sad to see) but as we reported previously here back in 2012, the judge can award the movie company a judgment against you for up to $150,000 for each movie plus attorney fees and costs!

If you want someone to look at your actual letter, call or tap (312) 201-8310. The review is free and confidential.

“I got a letter from my ISP saying Strike 3 Holdings subpoenaed my info. Can I just ignore it?”

The subpoena is aimed at your internet provider, not at you. Your provider is telling you that a federal court allowed Strike 3 Holdings to ask for the name and address on your account. If nothing is filed with the court before the date in your letter, providers generally turn that information over. Choosing to ignore a Strike 3 Holdings subpoena does not stop that from happening. It just means you skip the window when you can get advice while still anonymous.

“What actually happens if I ignore a Strike 3 Holdings subpoena?”

In general terms, the sequence looks like this:

  1. The provider releases the account holder’s name and address to Strike 3 Holdings’ attorneys after the notice period runs out.
  2. Strike 3 Holdings’ attorneys may reach out, or may ask the court for more time to decide what to do.
  3. Strike 3 Holdings can file an amended complaint that names a person instead of “John Doe.” That puts a name in the public court record. See what the amended complaint stage means.
  4. If a named defendant is formally served and does not respond to the lawsuit, the court can enter a default judgment.

Not every case goes through every step. Some cases are dismissed. Timelines vary by court and judge. But “ignore it and it disappears” is not a plan you can count on.

“Is this a scam?”

Scam letters exist, so it is smart to check. A real Strike 3 Holdings letter from a provider refers to a federal case number, such as 1:26-cv-00525, and a federal court. An attorney can confirm the docket in federal court records during a free, confidential review. Do not pay anyone or call a phone number in a letter until you know the case is real.

“I didn’t download anything. Do I still need to do anything?”

Maybe. The letter goes to the person who pays for the internet account. That person may not be the person who used the connection. Federal courts, including the Ninth Circuit in Cobbler Nevada v. Gonzales (2018), have said that being the subscriber is not enough by itself to show someone is the infringer.

“A plaintiff must allege something more to create a reasonable inference that a subscriber is also
an infringer.”

Cobbler Nevada v. Gonzales

Even so, if you ignore a Strike 3 Holdings subpoena, the account holder is still the one whose name gets released. Talking with a qualified, federal court experienced attorney before the date in your letter is how you protect your privacy and get your side considered.

“Should I call Strike 3’s lawyers and explain?”

Usually not on your own. What you say can be used against you; and, calling them identifies you before you understand your options. A defense attorney like Melissa Ross can communicate for you without giving out your name unless and until that makes sense.

“Can I just delete everything, factory-reset my stuff, or switch to a VPN?”

Do not delete files, wipe devices, or uninstall software after you get the letter. Destroying possible evidence can create a bigger problem than the original claim. Using a VPN from now on does not change what is alleged about the past.

“Will my name become public?”

At the subpoena stage, the case usually lists only an IP address. Names typically become public if a person is named in an amended complaint or files something with the court under their own name. Many people resolve these matters confidentially through counsel, often without their name ever appearing in the public record. See how anonymous settlements work.

“Should I file a motion to quash myself?”

A motion to quash is sometimes right, but a filing you make yourself can put your name in the public court record. Read why filing your own motion can affect your privacy first.

“How long do I have?”

Use the dates in your own letter and the court order in your case. Provider policies and court orders differ. For provider-specific details, see our pages on Comcast Xfinity, Verizon, AT&T Internet, Cox, Optimum, Frontier, and Spectrum.

What you Can Learn

Our short videos explain some of the important things to know about the Strike 3 Holdings lawsuit process, and your main options right now.

Many clients have told us our videos are very helpful. Click the image below to watch.

Strike 3: Start Here video playlist from Antonelli Law

Attorney Highlight: Melissa Ross

Melissa Ross, Senior Associate at Antonelli Law

Melissa Brabender Ross is a Senior Associate at Antonelli Law® since 2012. She represents clients in BitTorrent copyright defense and employment and labor law, and assists firm Principal Jeffrey Antonelli in the Drone/UAS Practice Group. She has represented clients in federal, state, and administrative proceedings, has substantial trial and deposition experience, and has successfully argued numerous contested substantive motions.

A native of Ohio, Melissa earned her Juris Doctor with honors from the DePaul University College of Law, where she was inducted into the Order of the Coif, and her Bachelor of Business Administration in Accounting with honors from the Ohio State University Fisher College of Business. She is licensed in Illinois and is a member of the General Bar of the Northern District of Illinois.

Phone: (312) 201-8310. Email: mross@antonelli-law.com.

Book with Melissa · Melissa’s bio

Clients Appreciate Our Communication & Results

Here is just one client review of Melissa Ross. Click the link below for many others.

Posted by anonymous | June 27, 2025 | Hired Attorney

Client review of Melissa Ross

“Woking with Melissa was fantastic. She was really effective in communicating with me in layman terms; translating legalize, explaining the process and making me feel I was in really good hands. She was always reachable and extremely prompt in communicating the back and forth between opposing counsel. I couldn’t have asked for more from Melissa. Because of the time zone, I was catching her late in her evenings and she always responded – THANK YOU. Sometimes you get lucky with the initial interview process, and I certainly did.”

View original review on Lawyers.com

Thinking about ignoring your Strike 3 Holdings letter?

Talk to us first. It is free and confidential. Most people we talk with want a quiet, anonymous resolution, and we also defend cases in court when that is the better path.

Call or tap: (312) 201-8310

Or email or upload your documents through our contact page, or choose an attorney and book a time below.

Schedule Your Free Confidential Strike 3 Holdings Consultation

Speak directly with our team. Choose the attorney you prefer. A consultation is not a decision to go to court.

Alec Dardis

Alec Dardis

Paul Sanders

Paul Sanders

Melissa Ross

Melissa Ross

Jeffrey Antonelli

Jeffrey Antonelli

Book a Free ConsultationCall (312) 201-8310

Frequently asked questions

Is it illegal to ignore a Strike 3 Holdings subpoena?

The subpoena is directed to your provider, so you are not breaking a rule by not responding to the letter itself. But if you ignore a Strike 3 Holdings subpoena, you give up the window to get advice while you are still anonymous.

Do I have to respond to Strike 3 Holdings directly?

No. You do not have to contact Strike 3 Holdings or its attorneys. If you hire counsel, your attorney handles communication.

Can a lawyer help if I live in a different state than the court?

Yes. Antonelli Law® handles Strike 3 Holdings matters in federal courts nationwide.

Related reading

This page is general information about Strike 3 Holdings and similar BitTorrent copyright cases. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different. Client reviews describe individual experiences. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Antonelli Law® defends people and businesses against copyright claims and does not represent copyright holders. Attorney advertising. Information is current as of October 23, 2026.

TORRENT DEFENDERS® is a federally registered trademark owned exclusively by the Law Offices of Jeffrey J. Antonelli, Ltd. dba Antonelli Law®.

Share

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.