Is Strike 3 Holdings a Scam?

Share

People often ask, “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?” after a letter from their internet provider about a copyright lawsuit.

No. Strike 3 Holdings is not a phishing scam. It is a real company, and the federal copyright lawsuits and internet-provider subpoena notices associated with its cases are real. A letter from your internet provider about a Strike 3 Holdings lawsuit is usually a serious legal document, not a fake invoice or a trick to steal a password or a payment card. That does not mean the account holder is guilty, and it does not mean you should pay a stranger who contacts you out of the blue. It means you should treat the notice as a real court matter and get advice before you respond, ignore it, or pay anyone.

As of November 2026, Antonelli Law® has represented more than 2,300 defendants in Strike 3 Holdings cases nationwide since 2017. The firm offers a free, confidential consultation.

If you are asking, “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?” because a letter arrived, you are not alone. Many people start with that question, then look at the court name and case number on the notice.

What is Strike 3 Holdings, and are the lawsuits real?

Strike 3 Holdings, LLC files federal copyright lawsuits over adult films released under brands that include Blacked, Vixen, and Tushy. A typical case is filed against a “John Doe” defendant identified only by an IP address. A federal court may then allow Strike 3 Holdings to subpoena the internet provider for the name and address of the account holder linked to that IP address. Your first notice is often a letter from the provider, not a summons handed to you at the door.

The company has been filing these cases in federal courts around the United States for years, and it is still filing new cases in 2026. It has also filed a copyright case against Meta Platforms, Inc. (Facebook) in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. Meta Platforms, Inc., No. 5:25-cv-06213 (filed July 23, 2025). On June 11, 2026, that court denied Meta’s motion to dismiss in full, which lets the case go forward; the order is not a finding that anyone infringed.

Those facts show a real company bringing real federal copyright cases. That is why the answer to “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?” is no: the company and the lawsuits are real. They do not decide the merits of any John Doe case, and an ISP letter is not a judgment that anyone did anything wrong.

How can I tell a real Strike 3 Holdings ISP letter from a fake?

If the question on your mind is, “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?”, start with the letter in your hand. A real notice usually has several of these features:

  • It comes from your internet provider — the company you already pay for service — often by mail or through that provider’s official account message or email, not from a stranger demanding immediate payment.
  • It names Strike 3 Holdings as the plaintiff, or encloses a subpoena or court order in a Strike 3 Holdings case.
  • It includes a federal court name and a full case number.
  • It tells you the provider has been asked for the account holder’s name and address, and it gives a deadline in that notice. The deadline varies by letter and court, so act fast. Use the date in your notice, not a date from someone else’s letter.
  • It does not typically ask you to pay Strike 3 Holdings by gift card, cryptocurrency, wire, or a random payment link in the same message.

Treat a message as suspicious if it is not from your provider and it demands immediate payment; if it asks for gift cards, crypto, a wire, or a bank transfer to “make this go away”; if it has no federal court name or full case number; or if it asks you to open an unexpected file or log into a site you do not recognize. Do not click a payment link, do not send money, and do not give out personal or financial information in response to a message like that.

If you are unsure whether a document is real, keep it as it is and talk with a lawyer who handles Strike 3 Holdings cases. A consultation can include a review of the letter and the case number. For a checklist of what a typical ISP notice looks like, see the Strike 3 Holdings ISP letter guide. A lawyer can also help you tell a real notice from a fake if you are still asking, “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?”

Why do people call Strike 3 Holdings a “copyright troll”?

“Copyright troll” is a criticism of a litigation model, not a finding that the company is fake or that its copyrights are fake. In these cases, the usual pattern is a wave of similar John Doe complaints, a request for a court-authorized ISP subpoena, and an effort to resolve many cases by settlement, often while the defendant is still unnamed.

In 2018, U.S. District Judge Royce C. Lamberth of the District of Columbia used that term in Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. Doe, No. 1:18-cv-01425, 351 F. Supp. 3d 160 (D.D.C. 2018). He wrote, “Strike 3 is also a copyright troll.” In the same opinion he wrote that Strike 3 “floods this courthouse (and others around the country) with lawsuits smacking of extortion,” that it “treats this Court not as a citadel of justice, but as an ATM,” and that its “feigned desire for legal process masks what it really seeks: for the Court to oversee a high-tech shakedown.” He denied early discovery in that case and dismissed it without prejudice.

That opinion is one judge’s ruling in one case. Other federal courts have allowed Strike 3 Holdings cases to proceed and have authorized ISP subpoenas, including in new cases filed in 2026. The criticism helps explain why people search “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam.” It does not make a real ISP letter safe to ignore, and it does not make a random payment demand safe to pay.

Does an IP address prove the account holder downloaded the films?

In a word, no. Supreme Court Justice Sotomayor explained why in her concurring opinion in the recent Cox Communications, Inc. v. Sony Music Entertainment copyright case. The lawsuit may be real, but that does not mean the account holder is automatically liable – which may be yet another reason people ask, “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?”

“When Cox receives a copyright violation notice, however, the notice specifies only which connection was used to infringe, not who used it to commit infringement.”

— Justice Sonia Sotomayor, concurring in the judgment, Cox Communications, Inc. v. Sony Music Entertainment, No. 24-171 (U.S. Mar. 25, 2026).

A court-authorized subpoena is simply permission for Strike 3 Holdings to ask the provider who it is that pays for the internet account linked to an IP address. It is not a judgment, and it is not a finding that the account holder downloaded anything. The account holder is not always the person who used the connection. An IP address alone does not prove that a particular person downloaded a file. Those are issues to review with a lawyer, based on the facts of the case.

What should I do if I received a letter?

Even if you asked, “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?”, a real ISP letter is still a legal matter. Do not ignore a letter that appears to be a real ISP notice or court document, and do not pay a person or a website that is simply demanding money. Find the deadline in your ISP notice, keep the letter and any enclosed documents, and do not delete files or contact Strike 3 Holdings yourself. Talk with a lawyer who handles Strike 3 Holdings cases, and act fast, ideally before the deadline in your notice.

For a step-by-step plan, see What to Do If You Get a Strike 3 Holdings ISP Subpoena Letter. If you are considering doing nothing, see Should I ignore a Strike 3 Holdings subpoena?.

While the case still names John Doe, people usually consider three paths: a quiet, anonymous resolution; a challenge to the subpoena, when the facts and the court make that appropriate; or a defense in federal court. Most people who contact the firm want a quiet, anonymous resolution. Court appearances are rarely necessary in these cases, and Antonelli Law® also defends in court when that is needed or is the better path. A consultation is a review of your documents, not a decision to settle or to litigate. See the pros and cons of settling with Strike 3 Holdings and the Strike 3 Holdings Defense Center.

How can Antonelli Law® help?

If you received a letter and still wonder, “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?”, Antonelli Law® can review the notice with you.

As of November 2026, Antonelli Law®, the Chicago firm behind Torrent Defenders®, has represented more than 2,300 defendants in Strike 3 Holdings cases nationwide since 2017. The firm represents clients in these federal cases in the United States, and you can work with it by phone, email, and upload. The consultation is free and confidential, and talking with the firm does not commit you to hiring it or to any particular path. Once you hire the firm, it communicates with Strike 3 Holdings’ attorneys on your behalf.

Call (312) 201-8310 or use the contact form for a free, confidential consultation. You can also read how to choose a Strike 3 Holdings defense lawyer and how the flat fee works.

The question “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?” is common. A free, confidential consultation is a chance to review your letter and the case number with a lawyer who handles these cases.

Attorney Highlight: Jeffrey Antonelli

Jeffrey Antonelli, Principal at Antonelli Law

Jeffrey Antonelli founded Antonelli Law® in Chicago in 2007 and still leads its BitTorrent Copyright Defense Group, along with its Drone/UAS Practice Group. He has spent nearly 25 years as a civil litigator in state and federal court, on both the plaintiff and defense side, for individuals and corporations alike. Earlier in his career he worked at several Chicago Loop litigation boutiques and a full-service firm, on software, data center contracts, business, insurance and consumer fraud disputes.

He belongs to the trial bar of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois and is admitted in many other federal courts nationwide. Jeffrey studied philosophy at Loyola University Chicago, then earned his law degree, with a health law certificate, at DePaul. Outlets including The New York Times, NBC, Bloomberg BNA, the Chicago Tribune, Chicago Lawyer and the Chicago Daily Law Bulletin have interviewed him.

Phone: (312) 201-8310. Email: Jeffrey@Antonelli-Law.com.

Book with Jeffrey · Jeffrey’s bio

Clients Appreciate Our Communication & Results

Here is just one client review of Jeffrey Antonelli. Click the link below for many others.

Posted by anonymous | June 15, 2026 | Hired Attorney

Copy write infringement case … Jeffrey is the best!

“I interviewed many lawyers for my copy write infringement case. Jeffrey stood out amongst all the lawyers as the most experienced and knowledgeable on dealing with such cases. He constantly kept me updated on the proceedings of the case, taking the time speaking at length with me on the phone. He was able to get a settlement on my behalf so that I could put this stressful situation behind me. I highly recommend Jeffrey.”

View original review on Avvo

Frequently asked questions

Is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?

No. The short answer to “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?” is no. Strike 3 Holdings is a real company, and its federal copyright lawsuits and ISP subpoena notices are real, not a phishing scam. A letter from your internet provider about a Strike 3 Holdings case is usually a serious legal document. It is not a judgment, and it is not a reason to pay a stranger who contacts you out of the blue.

How can I tell if my Strike 3 Holdings letter is real?

A real notice usually comes from your internet provider and includes a federal court name and a full case number. It may enclose a subpoena or a court order, and it gives a deadline in that notice. The deadline varies by letter and court, so act fast. Be cautious if a message is not from your provider and demands immediate payment, especially by gift card, cryptocurrency, wire, or a random payment link. If you are unsure, keep the document and ask a lawyer to review it.

Why do people say Strike 3 Holdings is a copyright troll?

The phrase is a criticism of a mass John Doe lawsuit and settlement model, not a finding that the company is fake. In 2018, U.S. District Judge Royce C. Lamberth called Strike 3 a “copyright troll” and described the approach as a “high-tech shakedown” in Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. Doe, No. 1:18-cv-01425 (D.D.C.). Other courts have allowed these cases to proceed. A real ISP letter is still a legal matter.

Does an IP address prove I downloaded the films?

In a word, no. Supreme Court Justice Sotomayor explained why in her concurring opinion in the recent Cox Communications, Inc. v. Sony Music Entertainment copyright case. The lawsuit may be real, but that does not mean the account holder is automatically liable – which may be yet another reason people ask, “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?”

A court-authorized subpoena is simply permission for Strike 3 Holdings to ask the provider who it is that pays for the internet account linked to an IP address. It is not a judgment, and it is not a finding that the account holder downloaded anything. The account holder is not always the person who used the connection. An IP address alone does not prove that a particular person downloaded a file. Those are issues to review with a lawyer, based on the facts of the case.

Should I ignore the letter or pay someone who emailed me?

No. If the notice is a real ISP letter and you do nothing, your provider may release the account holder’s name and address after the deadline in that notice, and Strike 3 Holdings may then name a person in an amended complaint. Do not ignore a court summons. Do not pay a person or a website that is simply demanding money. Talk with a lawyer before you respond or pay.

Do I need a lawyer in my state for a Strike 3 Holdings case?

No. Strike 3 Holdings cases are federal copyright cases. Antonelli Law® handles Strike 3 Holdings matters in federal courts nationwide, and you can work with the firm by phone, email, and upload.

How do I get a free consultation with Antonelli Law®?

Call (312) 201-8310 or use the contact form. You can email a PDF or photo of the letter.

Related reading

Once you know the answer to “is Strike 3 Holdings a scam?”, these guides explain what a real letter means and what to do next:

This page is general information about Strike 3 Holdings and similar BitTorrent copyright cases. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; results depend on the specific factual and legal circumstances of that case. Antonelli Law® defends people and businesses against copyright claims and does not represent copyright holders. The firm represents clients in these federal cases in the United States. Attorney advertising. Antonelli Law®, 100 N La Salle St, Suite 1111, Chicago, IL 60602, (312) 201-8310.

TORRENT DEFENDERS® is a federally registered trademark owned exclusively by the Law Offices of Jeffrey J. Antonelli, Ltd. dba Antonelli Law®.

Share