Strike 3 Holdings v. Meta (Facebook): What the Court Decided and What It Means

Share

In Strike 3 Holdings v. Meta, the same company behind thousands of John Doe BitTorrent cases against home internet subscribers is suing Meta Platforms, Inc. also known as Facebook. On June 11, 2026, the federal court in San Jose denied Meta’s motion to dismiss, and so the lawsuit was allowed to continue on. Here is what Strike 3 Holdings v. Meta is about, what the judge decided, where it stands as of November 11, 2026, and what it does and does not mean if you received an ISP letter.

What Strike 3 Holdings alleges against Meta

“Defendant’s infringement is intentional. Defendant downloaded Plaintiffs’ Works from pirate sources for purposes of acquiring content to train its Meta Movie Gen, Large Language Model (“LLaMA”), as well as various other Meta AI Models that rely on video training content.”

— Quoted from Paragraph 7 of the Amended Complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (Case No. 5:25-cv-06213, page 2). These are allegations; Meta disputes them.

Strike 3 Holdings v. Meta at a glance

Item Detail
Case Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. Meta Platforms, Inc.
Court U.S. District Court, Northern District of California (San Jose courthouse location)
Docket 5:25-cv-06213-EKL
Filed July 23, 2025
Plaintiffs Strike 3 Holdings, LLC and Counterlife Media, LLC
Judge District Judge Eumi K. Lee; Magistrate Judge Susan van Keulen
Key ruling Order denying Meta’s motion to dismiss, June 11, 2026
Status (Nov. 11, 2026) Pending. Meta has answered and the case is in discovery. The parties list March 4, 2027 for the close of fact discovery and February 7, 2028 for a jury trial.

Court documents

Docket City ISP Exhibit A Complaint Orders/other
5:25-cv-06213-EKL Menlo Park, CA (Meta headquarters) Not applicable (Meta corporate network) Not available Amended Complaint (July 7, 2026) PDF Order denying motion to dismiss (June 11, 2026) PDF
Discovery order (July 27, 2026) PDF

What Strike 3 Holdings alleges

The plaintiffs allege that Meta used BitTorrent to download their adult films in order to train generative AI models. According to the amended complaint, Meta has infringed at least 2,973 of the plaintiffs’ films since 2018, and 165 of those films were infringed through IP addresses directly owned by Meta. The plaintiffs say they found 47 IP addresses identified as owned by Facebook, and they also point to IP addresses on data center servers and at least one residential IP address of a Meta employee. These are allegations. Meta disputes them, and no court has found that Meta infringed.

What the court decided on June 11, 2026

In Strike 3 Holdings v. Meta, Meta asked the court to dismiss the case at the pleading stage. Judge Lee denied the motion. At this stage, the court asks only whether the complaint plausibly states a claim, not who is right. The court found:

  • Direct infringement was plausibly alleged. The court treated the torrenting itself as the alleged infringing act. The plaintiffs did not have to prove at this stage that the films were actually used to train a particular AI model.
  • The “IP address is not a person” argument did not win here. Meta relied on Cobbler Nevada, LLC v. Gonzales, 901 F.3d 1142 (9th Cir. 2018). In that case, the Ninth Circuit held that being the registered subscriber of an IP address is not enough, standing alone, to infer that the subscriber is the infringer. A plaintiff “must allege something more.” Judge Lee applied that rule and found the complaint alleged “something more.” The court pointed to alleged patterns across many corporate IP addresses that the plaintiffs say suggest coordinated, corporate activity rather than random individual use.
  • Vicarious infringement was plausibly alleged. The court found the plaintiffs alleged that Meta had the ability to control the activity and a financial interest in it. It compared AI training data to the music library in the Napster case.
  • Contributory infringement was plausibly alleged. The court found actual knowledge was alleged. It also applied the inducement standard from the Supreme Court’s 2026 decision in Cox Communications v. Sony Music.

What has happened since

  • July 7, 2026: the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint.
  • July 21, 2026: Meta filed its answer.
  • July 23, 2026: the parties mediated. The case did not settle, and further discussions were expected.
  • August 18, 2026: the court ordered a joint status report by October 21, 2026. Filings were made on October 21, 2026.
  • November 4, 2026: Strike 3 Holdings filed a renewed administrative motion asking the court to treat a separate Strike 3 Holdings John Doe case in the same court as related to this one. Strike 3 Holdings says the subscriber in that John Doe case was a Meta executive. An administrative motion about sealing material was filed the same day.
  • November 5, 2026: the parties filed a joint discovery letter. Strike 3 Holdings asks the court to order Meta to search for and produce documents. Meta says the request is improper and should be denied.
  • November 9, 2026: Meta opposed the motion to relate the cases. Meta says the subscriber stopped working for Meta in February 2025, before the alleged downloading began.
  • November 10, 2026: the court entered an order, and the clerk issued a notice setting a hearing by Zoom.

Strike 3 Holdings v. Meta remains pending. A denial of a motion to dismiss is not a finding of liability. Meta can still contest the facts, and the case could end in many ways.

What Strike 3 Holdings v. Meta means if you got an ISP letter

  • The Cobbler Nevada rule still matters. The court restated the Ninth Circuit rule that subscriber status alone is not enough. It found “something more” only because of the specific allegations against a large company with many IP addresses. A household subscriber’s case is different, and the facts matter.
  • It does not change your deadline. Your dates come from the court order in your case and your provider’s letter.
  • It shows Strike 3 Holdings litigates. Strike 3 Holdings is willing to take on a very large defendant. That is a reason to take your letter seriously and calmly, not to panic.
  • It does not mean your case will go to trial. Most people we talk with want a quiet, anonymous resolution. Court appearances are rarely necessary, and the firm defends in court when needed.

Attorney Highlight: Alec Dardis

Alec Dardis, Associate at Antonelli Law

Alec Dardis is an Associate at Antonelli Law®. Born and raised in Southern California (Orange County area), he was a competitive junior tennis player and captain of the Men’s Division 1 tennis team at Colgate University, where he earned a Bachelor of Arts in Philosophy. He later received the Dean’s Scholarship to DePaul University College of Law, earned a CALI Award in Negotiations, made Dean’s List, and graduated with a Juris Doctor and a Certificate in Intellectual Property. He is licensed in Illinois and handles federal copyright matters nationwide.

In the firm’s BitTorrent practice, Alec has personally assisted hundreds of clients with cases involving copyright holders, including Strike 3 Holdings. He handles the consultation, the reading of the letter, settlement talks when that is what the client wants, and court defense when that is the better path.

Phone: (312) 201-8310. Email: adardis@antonelli-law.com.

Book with Alec · Alec’s bio

Clients Appreciate Our Communication & Results

Here is just one client review of Alec Dardis. Click the link below for many others.

Posted by anonymous | September 30, 2026 | Hired Attorney

Highly Recommend Alec Van Dardis

“We had a consultation with Alec and he explained our options in detail. He made us feel comfortable and gave us time to ask a lot of questions. At the end of the consultation we made another appointment so we could decide which option to take. We felt that we were in good hands starting with consultation. Alec was thorough in explaining every step, what we needed to do and the timing. He was a great communicator, always followed up and very professional. We are very grateful for all Alec did to get this case closed. We would highly recommend Alec to others that need his expertise.”

View original review on Avvo

Got a Strike 3 Holdings ISP letter?

Most people we talk with want a quiet, anonymous resolution. Court appearances are rarely necessary, and the firm defends in court when needed. The first step is simply a free, confidential consultation about your letter and the documents in your case.

Call or tap: (312) 201-8310

Or upload your letter securely, email us a PDF or photo through our contact page, or choose an attorney and book a time below.

Upload your ISP letter or subpoena notice securely and our team will review it.

Upload your ISP letter (PDF or photo)

Your information and documents will be treated confidentially. No attorney-client relationship is formed until you speak with an Antonelli Law® attorney, sign an attorney agreement, and pay the legal fee.

Prefer email? You can also email a PDF or photo of the letter from the contact form or to the firm.

Schedule Your Free Confidential Strike 3 Holdings Consultation

Speak directly with our team. Choose the attorney you prefer. A consultation is not a decision to go to court.

Jeffrey Antonelli

Jeffrey Antonelli

Alec Dardis

Alec Dardis

Paul Sanders

Paul Sanders

Melissa Ross

Melissa Ross

Book a Free ConsultationCall (312) 201-8310

Frequently asked questions

Did Strike 3 Holdings win against Meta?

No. On June 11, 2026, the court denied Meta’s motion to dismiss. That lets the case go forward. It is not a finding that Meta infringed. As of November 11, 2026, Strike 3 Holdings v. Meta is pending.

What is the case number?

Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. Meta Platforms, Inc., No. 5:25-cv-06213-EKL (N.D. Cal.).

Does this ruling affect my John Doe case?

Not directly. Each case depends on its own court and facts. The ruling restates the Ninth Circuit rule that subscriber status alone is not enough to show someone is the infringer. Antonelli Law® is following Strike 3 Holdings v. Meta because it deals with BitTorrent copyright infringement claims and involves circumstances and legal findings that could turn out to be novel in the California federal District Court. AI is an important issue for society and the law, and Antonelli Law® has been following it closely for over a year.

What happened in Strike 3 Holdings v. Meta in November 2026?

Strike 3 Holdings asked the court on November 4, 2026 to relate a separate John Doe case, saying that subscriber was a Meta executive, and Meta opposed on November 9. The parties filed a joint discovery letter on November 5, and on November 10 the court entered an order and set a hearing by Zoom.

Will I have to go to court if I got an ISP letter?

Usually not. Court appearances are rarely necessary in Strike 3 Holdings cases, and the firm defends in court when needed. Most people we talk with want a quiet, anonymous resolution.

Related reading

This page is general information about Strike 3 Holdings and similar BitTorrent copyright cases. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; results depend on the specific factual and legal circumstances of that case. Client reviews describe individual experiences; past results do not guarantee a similar result. Antonelli Law® defends people and businesses against copyright claims and does not represent copyright holders. Attorney advertising. Information is current as of November 11, 2026.

TORRENT DEFENDERS® is a federally registered trademark owned exclusively by the Law Offices of Jeffrey J. Antonelli, Ltd. dba Antonelli Law®.

Share

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.