Judge Denies Strike 3 Holdings Subpoena in Jacksonville: What It Means (Nov 2026)

Share

On November 19, 2026, a Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order Jacksonville ruling denied, without prejudice, the request to subpoena AT&T Internet in 3:26-cv-02965. Strike 3 Holdings can file again, likely after fixing the declarations the court flagged. This order does not authorize the provider to identify the subscriber. A provider letter would not follow from this ruling.

This Torrent Defenders® explainer is educational. It is not legal advice. Antonelli Law® defends people and businesses against copyright claims. We do not represent copyright holders. A call is not a decision to go to trial. Most people who contact us want a quiet, confidential resolution. We also defend these cases in federal court when that is the better path.

The full case table for the October 28, 2026 Middle District of Florida wave, including Exhibit A details and the complaints, is on our Strike 3 Holdings Florida filings page. For a wider view of the Florida courts and earlier posts, see the Strike 3 Holdings Florida lawsuits hub. This page focuses on the November 19 Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order Jacksonville ruling in 3:26-cv-02965 and what it means if an AT&T Internet letter arrives.

What the November 19 Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order in Jacksonville did

On November 19, 2026, Magistrate Judge Samuel J. Horovitz entered an endorsed order in Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. Doe, No. 3:26-cv-02965, in the Jacksonville Division of the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida. The case is assigned to Senior Judge Brian J. Davis and referred to Magistrate Judge Horovitz. Strike 3 Holdings had moved on November 12, 2026 (ECF 7) for leave to serve a third-party subpoena on the internet provider before the usual discovery conference. The November 19 order (ECF 8) denied that motion without prejudice.

“Without prejudice” means the court did not shut the door on a later request. Strike 3 Holdings can file again, likely after addressing the problem the court described in the declarations. The order does not dismiss the lawsuit, and it is not a decision about whether any copyright was infringed. In short, the Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order Jacksonville ruling leaves the case open and leaves the door open for a later, corrected request.

Why the court denied the motion

The motion that led to the Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order Jacksonville denial relied on sworn declarations, including one from Patrick Paige and one from Jorge Arco. Those declarations are the kind of evidence Strike 3 Holdings typically uses to support an early subpoena, including how the company says it detected the alleged infringement. Magistrate Judge Horovitz did not decide whether a subpoena should be allowed on a corrected record. He denied the request because of a date problem in the documents already on file:

“The Motion relies in part on declarations from [7-2] Patrick Paige and [7-1] Jorge Arco. The former declaration indicates that the declarant has read the latter and makes certain assertions based on that review. Doc. 7-2 at 6. But the former declaration is dated earlier, making the basis for the assertions supporting the Motion unclear.”

Magistrate Judge Samuel J. Horovitz, Endorsed Order, Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. Doe, No. 3:26-cv-02965 (M.D. Fla. Nov. 19, 2026) (ECF 8).

In plain terms, the Paige declaration (ECF 7-2) indicated that Paige had read the Arco declaration (ECF 7-1) and made certain assertions based on that review. But the Paige declaration was dated earlier than the Arco declaration, so the court could not tell what those assertions were based on. The reliability of the infringement-detection evidence, as presented in those declarations, was therefore unclear. The court did not say the evidence could never support a subpoena. It said the basis for the assertions supporting this motion was unclear, and it denied the request without prejudice. 

The Jacksonville case at a glance

This page covers only 3:26-cv-02965, not the full October 28 Florida table. The city, internet provider, and works count below come from Exhibit A to the complaint. The case was filed on October 28, 2026. The Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order Jacksonville entry is the endorsed order entered as ECF 8.

Docket City ISP Works listed November 19 order
3:26-cv-02965
Exhibit A · Complaint
Jacksonville, FL AT&T Internet 33 Denied without prejudice (ECF 8)

The first digit of the docket number is the courthouse location. In the Middle District of Florida, “3:” is Jacksonville. As of November 19, 2026, that docket’s Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order Jacksonville ruling is a denial without prejudice.

What this means if you may get an AT&T Internet letter

A provider letter normally follows a court order granting permission to subpoena the internet provider. The November 19 Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order Jacksonville ruling did not grant that permission in 3:26-cv-02965, so this order does not authorize AT&T Internet to turn over the subscriber’s information. If Strike 3 Holdings files again and a later order grants leave, a letter could still follow. Plan around the date printed in any letter you actually receive.

The order itself is not a letter to the subscriber, and it is not a summons naming anyone. The defendant remains a John Doe in the caption for now. If a letter is already on the table, start with the full case number on that letter. AT&T Internet subscribers can also read our Strike 3 Holdings AT&T Internet letter guide. More background is in the Strike 3 Holdings ISP notices guide and the Strike 3 Holdings Defense Center.

What you Can Learn

Our short videos explain some of the important things to know about the Strike 3 Holdings lawsuit process, and your main options right now.

Many clients have told us our videos are very helpful. Click the image below to watch.

Strike 3: Start Here video playlist from Antonelli Law

Got an AT&T Internet letter about a Strike 3 Holdings Jacksonville case?

If you received a letter about a Strike 3 Holdings Jacksonville case, including the Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order Jacksonville matter in 3:26-cv-02965, most people we talk with want a quiet, anonymous resolution. Court appearances are rarely necessary, and we also defend cases in court when that is the better path. The fastest way to get started is to send us the letter.

If a Strike 3 Holdings letter does arrive, this short from Antonelli Law® covers what not to do and the three main options people usually consider:

youtube placeholder image

Got a Strike 3 Subpoena Letter? What Not to Do and Your 3 Options (YouTube Short by Antonelli Law®)

Got the letter? Upload a PDF or photo and an attorney will review it with you in a free, confidential consultation.

Upload your ISP letter (PDF or photo)

Your information and documents will be treated confidentially. No attorney-client relationship is formed until you speak with an Antonelli Law® attorney, sign an attorney agreement, and pay the legal fee.

Prefer email? You can also email a PDF or photo of the letter from the contact page.

Attorney Highlight: Alec Dardis

Alec Dardis, Associate at Antonelli Law

Alec Dardis is an Associate at Antonelli Law®. Born and raised in Southern California (Orange County area), he was a competitive junior tennis player and captain of the Men’s Division 1 tennis team at Colgate University, where he earned a Bachelor of Arts in Philosophy. He later received the Dean’s Scholarship to DePaul University College of Law, earned a CALI Award in Negotiations, made Dean’s List, and graduated with a Juris Doctor and a Certificate in Intellectual Property. He is licensed in Illinois and handles federal copyright matters nationwide.

In the firm’s BitTorrent practice, Alec has personally assisted hundreds of clients with cases involving copyright holders, including Strike 3 Holdings. He handles the consultation, the reading of the letter, settlement talks when that is what the client wants, and court defense when that is the better path.

Phone: (312) 201-8310. Email: adardis@antonelli-law.com.

Book with Alec · Alec’s bio

Clients Appreciate Our Communication & Results

Here is just one client review of Alec Dardis. Click the link below for many others.

Posted by anonymous | November 18, 2026 | Hired Attorney

Highly Recommend

“Alec was fantastic throughout every phase of my case (copyright infringement), from consultation to negotiations to settlement. As frightened as I was about everything at first, Alec managed to calm my stress by keeping me informed every step of the way and handling things in a very professional and timely manner. I would highly recommend Alec Dardis for anyone with a similar issue.”

View original review on Avvo

Clients we have represented in Florida

Antonelli Law® has represented 197 clients who live in Florida in federal copyright matters. We handle Strike 3 Holdings Florida matters by phone, email, and secure upload through our contact page, so you do not need to travel to Jacksonville, Orlando, Tampa, or Fort Myers to talk with us.

Our Florida clients have lived in Apopka, Aventura, Boca Raton, Boynton Beach, Bradenton, Brandon, Casselberry, Clearwater, Clermont, Coconut Creek, Cooper City, Crestview, Davenport, DeLand, Delray Beach, Edgewater, Estero, Eustis, Fernandina, Fort Lauderdale, Fort Myers, Groveland, Hollywood, Jacksonville, Jacksonville Beach, Jupiter, Kissimmee, Lake Mary, Lake Worth, Land O Lakes, Largo, Lauderhill, Lehigh Acres, Longwood, Lutz, Lynn Haven, Marco Island, Margate, Mascotte, Melbourne, Miami, Miami Beach, Middleburg, Miramar, and Naples.

They have also lived in New Port Richey, Newberry, North Miami, North Palm Beach, Ocala, Ocoee, Odessa, Orange Park, Orlando, Oviedo, Palm Bay, Palm Beach Gardens, Palm City, Palm Coast, Palm Springs, Palmetto Bay, Pembroke Pines, Pinecrest, Plant City, Plantation, Port Richey, Rockledge, Safety Harbor, Sanford, Sarasota, Sebring, Spring Hill, St. Augustine, St. Johns, St. Petersburg, Stuart, Sunrise, Tamarac, Tampa, Tarpon Springs, Venice, Wellington, Wesley Chapel, West Palm Beach, Weston, Winter Garden, Winter Haven, Winter Park, Winter Springs, and Yulee.

Frequently asked questions: Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order Jacksonville

Do I need a Florida lawyer for a Strike 3 Holdings case?

No. Strike 3 Holdings Florida cases are federal copyright cases. Antonelli Law® handles Strike 3 Holdings matters in federal courts nationwide, and you can work with us by phone, email, and upload. Court appearances are rarely necessary, and we also defend clients in court when that is needed.

What did the November 19, 2026 Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order in Jacksonville do?

The November 19, 2026 Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order Jacksonville ruling denied, without prejudice, Strike 3 Holdings’ motion for leave to serve a third-party subpoena on the internet provider in 3:26-cv-02965 (ECF 8). The court pointed to a date inconsistency between the Patrick Paige and Jorge Arco declarations. A denial without prejudice means the company can file the request again.

Does a denial without prejudice mean the Jacksonville case is over?

No. The November 19 order denied only the request for early leave to subpoena the internet provider. It did not dismiss 3:26-cv-02965. Strike 3 Holdings can file that request again, likely after addressing the declaration dates the court flagged. Every case is different; results depend on the specific factual and legal circumstances of that case.

I have an AT&T Internet letter about a Strike 3 Holdings Jacksonville case. What should I do first?

Read the full case number and the date printed in the letter before you call anyone. This November 19 order does not authorize AT&T Internet to identify the subscriber in 3:26-cv-02965. If your letter lists a different docket number, start with our AT&T Internet letter guide and the October 28 Florida filings page. You can also upload a PDF or photo of the letter and schedule a free, confidential consultation.

Related reading

For the rest of the October 28 Middle District of Florida wave, and for broader Florida and ISP-letter guides, start here. This page stays focused on the Strike 3 Holdings subpoena order Jacksonville ruling.

Every case is different; results depend on the specific factual and legal circumstances of that case. This page is educational and is not legal advice. Past results do not guarantee a similar result. Antonelli Law® defends people and businesses against copyright claims and does not represent copyright holders. Attorney advertising. Information is current as of November 19, 2026.

TORRENT DEFENDERS® is a federally registered trademark owned exclusively by the Law Offices of Jeffrey J. Antonelli, Ltd. dba Antonelli Law®.

Share