Strike 3 Holdings Fee Awards and Litigation: When Fighting a Case Realistically Makes Sense
Short answer on a Strike 3 Holdings fee award: a court can order Strike 3 Holdings to pay a defendant’s attorney’s fees, but only after the defendant wins, and only if the judge decides an award is fair. That has happened in a Washington case filed on November 16, 2017, just over nine years ago, after years of litigation, for a subscriber whose hard drive was forensically examined and showed none of the listed works.
For most people who receive an ISP letter, a quiet, anonymous resolution is the realistic path. If you did not do it and the facts hold up, defending the case in court can make sense, and Antonelli Law® defends clients in court when that is needed. If you have a letter, call or tap (312) 201-8310 for a free, confidential consultation.
First: an ISP letter does not mean you have been named or sued
An ISP letter means your internet provider received a subpoena asking for the name of the account holder assigned to an IP address. It does not mean you have been named as a defendant, and it does not mean you have been served.
The deadline in the letter varies by letter and court, so read it carefully and act fast (see should I ignore a Strike 3 Holdings subpoena?). Our Strike 3 Holdings ISP letter guide walks through what the letter says.
What is a Strike 3 Holdings fee award?
The Copyright Act lets a federal judge award reasonable attorney’s fees to the party that wins a copyright case (17 U.S.C. § 505). A Strike 3 Holdings fee award is not automatic.
The judge weighs factors such as whether the claim was frivolous or objectively unreasonable, the losing party’s motivation, and the need to compensate or deter. A defendant has to win first, and then has to persuade the judge that a Strike 3 Holdings fee award should be paid.
What a real Strike 3 Holdings fee award case looked like
Filed November 16, 2017: just over nine years ago. This Strike 3 Holdings fee award case, 2:17-cv-01731 (the “17” is the filing year), began in 2017 and ended in 2021.
In Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. John Doe, No. 2:17-cv-01731 (W.D. Wash.), the public court record shows:
- The case was filed on November 16, 2017, just over nine years ago.
- Strike 3 Holdings voluntarily dismissed its own infringement claim on August 23, 2018. The subscriber kept going on a counterclaim asking the court to declare that he had not infringed.
- A forensic examiner imaged the subscriber’s hard drive and found none of the works listed in Exhibit A.
- On January 31, 2020 the court granted the subscriber summary judgment (order, Dkt. 188, PDF).
- The February 3, 2020 judgment declared that the subscriber had not infringed any of the listed works and awarded $40,501.63 in attorney’s fees and $7,275.63 in costs, $47,777.26 in total (judgment, Dkt. 189, PDF).
- Strike 3 Holdings appealed. The Ninth Circuit affirmed on March 18, 2021 in No. 20-35196 (memorandum, PDF), and the judgment was satisfied on May 7, 2021.
| Date | Strike 3 Holdings fee award case 2:17-cv-01731 (W.D. Wash.) |
|---|---|
| November 16, 2017 (just over 9 years ago) | Strike 3 Holdings files the case against a John Doe subscriber |
| August 23, 2018 | Strike 3 Holdings voluntarily dismisses its infringement claim; the subscriber continues on his counterclaim |
| January 31, 2020 | Summary judgment for the subscriber after the forensic exam found none of the Exhibit A works |
| February 3, 2020 | Judgment: $40,501.63 attorney’s fees + $7,275.63 costs = $47,777.26 |
| March 18, 2021 | Ninth Circuit affirms (No. 20-35196) |
| May 7, 2021 | Satisfaction of judgment filed |
That Strike 3 Holdings fee award was real and it mattered. It also took about three and a half years from filing to final payment, a forensic examination of the subscriber’s own computer, a full round of motions, and an appeal.
The Ninth Circuit also noted that Strike 3 Holdings admitted at oral argument it was nearly certain another member of the household was the infringer, which shows that a household can still face hard questions even when the account holder is cleared.
What the court said about the Strike 3 Holdings fee award amount
Even the winning subscriber did not recover the full defense bill. The fee request had already been trimmed before the judge ruled, and the judge then explained why the reduced amount was reasonable:
“In outlining the services for which John Doe is requesting attorney’s fees, his lawyers have carefully segregated between the successful and unsuccessful defenses, counterclaims, and motions, and the amount sought is narrowly tailored to the matters on which John Doe prevailed.”
One of the defense firms “. . . has significantly curtailed the amount requested on behalf of John Doe by not including any time billed after August 23, 2018, when Strike 3 dismissed its copyright infringement claim, and by applying a 50% reduction to all other fees.”
“Having reviewed the materials submitted by John Doe, the Court concludes that the requested hourly rates are commensurate with the amounts charged by lawyers of similar skill in the local legal community for comparable work, and that the following attorney’s fees are reasonable under all of the circumstances”
Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. John Doe, No. 2:17-cv-01731-TSZ (W.D. Wash.), Order, Dkt. 188, at 14–15 (dated Jan. 31, 2020; filed Feb. 3, 2020). Read the court’s order (PDF).
Costs were cut too. For one defense firm’s costs, the court excluded items Strike 3 Holdings objected to and awarded half of the rest. In the order’s words, “Excluding those items results in costs of $9,234.85, half of which will be awarded, or $4,617.43.” (Dkt. 188, at 15.)
A word from Jeffrey Antonelli on fee awards and the risk of a long fight
Not getting back every dollar of attorney’s fees you have already paid is a fact of life that every corporate litigant knows. Anyone considering a drawn-out legal fight is, or at least should be, counseled on it by their attorney. The reduction a court applies to the winning side’s bill may not be as large as the 50% reduction in this case, but anyone considering a legal fight that could cost $50,000 to $100,000 or more should be willing to absorb that fee-reduction risk.
The American Bar Association’s Litigation News describes how much room a federal judge has to trim a fee request:
“It is within the discretion of the court to reduce an award for attorney fees up to ten percent without offering an explanation for the reduction, and a court can further reduce an award if the movant’s supporting documents are inadequate or include hours not reasonably expended.”
— Jeffrey Michael Marchese, “Judge Slashes Attorney Fees by 83 Percent in Privacy Class Action,” ABA Litigation News (June 29, 2026).
And you only get a fee award if you actually win the case. Winning is not guaranteed for either side. In our observation, that is a major reason why so few Strike 3 Holdings cases ever reach a trial, and why a defendant who wins and is then awarded attorney’s fees is so rare.
“With well over 20,000 federal lawsuits filed by Strike 3 Holdings since 2017, the number of cases ending in a trial or the defendant winning and getting their attorneys fees awarded to them can be counted on one hand.”
— Jeffrey Antonelli, Antonelli Law®
Why most people are not in line for a Strike 3 Holdings fee award
Strike 3 Holdings has filed more than 20,000 federal cases since 2017. A Strike 3 Holdings fee award is a court’s decision in one case, on that case’s facts. It is not a plan most people can count on. Litigating toward a Strike 3 Holdings fee award realistically depends on all of these:
- You did not do it, and no one else on your network did either. The question is not only the account holder. Family members, roommates, guests, and open or shared Wi-Fi all matter.
- The facts hold up under examination. Expect to make your devices available for a forensic examination and to answer questions under oath.
- You can carry the cost and the time while the case runs. Fees are only recovered at the end, if at all, and the judge decides the amount.
- You are comfortable with a contested federal case. Litigation can bring discovery, depositions, and court filings, and it can take years.
- The plaintiff keeps the case going, or you have a claim of your own. A plaintiff can dismiss its own claim. In the Washington case the subscriber continued on his own counterclaim, and whether a defendant can still pursue fees after a dismissal depends on the court and the facts.
What most clients choose instead of chasing a Strike 3 Holdings fee award
Most people who receive an ISP letter want a quiet, anonymous resolution, not a Strike 3 Holdings fee award fight. Court appearances are rarely necessary in Strike 3 Holdings matters, and the work is usually done by phone, email, and written documents. That is not a promise about any one case.
When the facts truthfully show you did not do it, we start there, and Antonelli Law® also defends clients in court when that is needed or is the better path. Our anonymous settlement and settlement cost guides explain the quieter route, and our motion to quash page covers early court challenges.
Antonelli Law® has represented more than 2,300 defendants in Strike 3 Holdings cases nationwide since 2017.
How we look at your options, including a Strike 3 Holdings fee award
- We review your ISP letter and the court documents for your case.
- We talk through who had access to your network and what your devices would show, which is the starting point for any Strike 3 Holdings fee award.
- We explain, in plain terms, what settling, waiting, and defending would each involve for you, including cost and time.
- You decide. Our flat fee is explained before you commit.
What you Can Learn
Our short videos explain some of the important things to know about the Strike 3 Holdings lawsuit process, and your main options right now.
Many clients have told us our videos are very helpful. Click the image below to watch.
Got an ISP letter? Talk through a Strike 3 Holdings fee award question, free and confidential
Jeffrey Antonelli has been licensed to practice law since 2000. Antonelli Law® represents clients in Strike 3 Holdings cases in federal courts nationwide from our office at 100 N La Salle St, Suite 1111, Chicago, Illinois. The fastest way to start is to send us the letter.
Got the letter? Upload a PDF or photo and an attorney will review it with you in a free, confidential consultation.
Upload your ISP letter (PDF or photo)Your information and documents will be treated confidentially. No attorney-client relationship is formed until you speak with an Antonelli Law® attorney, sign an attorney agreement, and pay the legal fee.
Prefer email? You can also email a PDF or photo of the letter from the contact page.
Attorney Highlight: Melissa Ross
Melissa Brabender Ross lives outside Columbus and is a graduate of the Ohio State University Fisher College of Business. Melissa is Senior Associate at Antonelli Law®, and handles BitTorrent copyright defense, employment, and labor matters. She also works with Jeffrey Antonelli in the firm’s Drone/UAS Practice Group. She has appeared in federal, state and administrative proceedings, has extensive trial and deposition experience, and has won many contested substantive motions.
Originally from Ohio, Melissa graduated with honors from DePaul University College of Law and was elected to the Order of the Coif. She is licensed in Illinois and admitted to the General Bar of the Northern District of Illinois.
Phone: (312) 201-8310. Email: mross@antonelli-law.com.
Clients Appreciate Our Communication & Results
Melissa Ross can help you weigh settling against defending a Strike 3 Holdings case. Here is just one client review of Melissa Ross. Click the link below for many others.
“Her original estimate for settling was SPOT ON and the settlement was reached within a week.”
Posted by anonymous | November 02, 2026 | Hired Attorney
Client review of Melissa Ross
“Melissa Ross was my attorney. This was a very difficult situation for me as I’ve never dealt with a legal issue. Melissa was so helpful, compassionate to my situation and communicated with me virtually everyday. At the start of our initial consultation, I knew right away I wanted to retain her. Although, we settled for more then I anticipated, I completely trusted her opinions and thoughts. Her original estimate for settling was SPOT ON and the settlement was reached within a week. She was very knowledgeable of the copyright laws. If anyone else gets themselves in this situation, I would recommend highly Melissa.”
Wondering whether a Strike 3 Holdings fee award or a court defense is realistic for you?
Most people we talk with want a quiet, anonymous resolution. Court appearances are rarely necessary, and we also defend cases in court when that is the better path. The first step is simply a free, confidential consultation about your documents.
Call or tap: (312) 201-8310
Or upload your letter securely, email us a PDF or photo through our contact page, or choose an attorney and book a time below.
Schedule Your Free Confidential Strike 3 Holdings Consultation
Speak directly with our team. Choose the attorney you prefer. A consultation is not a decision to go to court.
Jeffrey Antonelli
Alec Dardis
Paul Sanders
Melissa Ross
Frequently asked questions: Strike 3 Holdings fee award
Can I make Strike 3 Holdings pay my attorney’s fees?
Yes, but only if you win the case and the judge decides an award is appropriate. A Strike 3 Holdings fee award has happened, after years of litigation and a forensic examination of the subscriber’s computer. It is not a realistic plan for most people who receive an ISP letter.
How much was the Strike 3 Holdings fee award in the Washington case?
The February 3, 2020 judgment in 2:17-cv-01731 (W.D. Wash.) awarded $40,501.63 in attorney’s fees and $7,275.63 in costs, $47,777.26 in total. The fee request had already left out time billed after Strike 3 Holdings dismissed its claim, and one defense firm applied a 50% reduction to its other fees before the court found the amount reasonable. We give kudos to those defense firms for the results they obtained for their client.
If I did not do it, should I fight?
Maybe. It depends on who else used your network, what your devices would show, and how much time and cost you can carry. We start with your facts and explain each option before you decide.
Does my ISP letter mean I have been sued?
No. An ISP letter means your provider received a subpoena for the account holder’s name. It does not mean you have been named or served.
Do I need a lawyer in my state for a Strike 3 Holdings case?
No. Strike 3 Holdings cases are federal copyright cases. Antonelli Law® handles Strike 3 Holdings matters in federal courts nationwide, and you can work with us by phone, email, and secure upload.
Will I have to go to court?
Court appearances are rarely necessary in Strike 3 Holdings matters. Most people we talk with want a quiet, anonymous resolution. If your case does need a court defense, Antonelli Law® defends clients in court.
Related reading
- Strike 3 Holdings ISP letter guide
- Strike 3 Holdings Defense Center
- Strike 3 Holdings settlement cost: a clear guide to fees
- Strike 3 Holdings flat fee
- Strike 3 Holdings anonymous settlement
- Strike 3 Holdings motion to quash
- Strike 3 Holdings: when a defendant’s name becomes public
Court website: U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington.
This page is general information about Strike 3 Holdings and similar BitTorrent copyright cases. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; results depend on the specific factual and legal circumstances of that case. Client reviews describe individual experiences; past results do not guarantee a similar result. Antonelli Law® defends people and businesses against copyright claims and does not represent copyright holders. Attorney advertising. Information is current as of November 18, 2026.
TORRENT DEFENDERS® is a federally registered trademark owned exclusively by the Law Offices of Jeffrey J. Antonelli, Ltd. dba Antonelli Law®.


